Ticketing for dangerous driving: A life-saving measure, but is it enough on Long Island?
In the bustling streets of Long Island, a debate rages on: Are we doing enough to keep our roads safe? Melville resident Jeff Redelman, a daily commuter to Ronkonkoma, has witnessed a disturbing trend - an increase in reckless driving behaviors. From speeding to lane weaving, these actions put lives at risk. But here's the catch: Redelman believes there's a lack of enforcement, a sentiment shared by many.
"It's like an open season for dangerous drivers," he says, noting the stark contrast in police presence when he travels upstate. So, why the discrepancy? Let's dive into the numbers and explore the controversial topic of traffic enforcement.
The Numbers Don't Lie: A Comparative Analysis
A Newsday analysis reveals an interesting trend. Suffolk County, despite its efforts, issues significantly fewer dangerous driving tickets compared to other regions in New York when adjusted for traffic volume. Nassau County, on the other hand, has a higher ticketing rate, but it hasn't fully recovered from the COVID-19 pandemic's impact on enforcement.
In 2024, Suffolk law enforcement issued approximately 94,000 safety-related tickets, a notable increase but still lagging behind Nassau, the Lower Hudson Valley, and upstate regions. Nassau, with about 84,000 tickets, is closer to upstate rates but still below its pre-pandemic levels.
A Complex Web: Comparing Ticketing Rates
Comparing ticketing rates between individual police departments is a challenge due to the lack of official traffic volume data at that level. The data available is at the county level, making precise comparisons difficult. However, experts argue that comparisons are essential in the era of transparent policing.
Suffolk's Response: Prioritizing Traffic Enforcement
Commissioner Kevin Catalina of the Suffolk County Police Department, the largest in the county, has made traffic enforcement a priority since taking the helm. He's expanded the highway patrol and emphasized the importance of traffic enforcement for career advancement. Catalina believes Suffolk should be compared to itself, highlighting the unique roadway system and public safety needs of the county.
"We're making progress," Catalina asserts, pointing to a significant increase in ticketing for speeding and aggressive driving in 2025 compared to the previous year. He also highlights the department's Street Takeover Task Force, formed to combat street racing, as a success.
The Expert Take: A Balanced Approach
Christopher Mercado, a former NYPD lieutenant and adjunct professor, agrees that each region has unique needs. While comparisons are useful, he believes Suffolk could do more. "Catalina is the right person for the job," he adds, emphasizing the need for a balanced approach.
The State Police Perspective: Visibility Over Numbers
Captain Timothy Gleason of the New York State Police's Troop L, which patrols state parkways in Nassau and Suffolk, declines to compare ticketing rates. For him, it's about visibility and being out there, not just about the numbers.
The Debate Continues: Ticketing's Role in Road Safety
Advocates argue that traffic safety is a holistic approach, encompassing better road designs, driver education, and legal changes. Ticketing, especially for safety-related violations, plays a crucial role in taking bad drivers off the road and deterring others. Effective patrolling can create a safe driving culture, as seen in a study on Oregon's sudden decrease in ticketing.
Kacie Dragan, a public health professor, highlights the critical role of police ticketing in New York City's Vision Zero program. However, over-ticketing can also be problematic, especially when it comes to allegations of racial profiling and revenue-raising tactics.
Addressing Bias and Fairness: A National Challenge
Ben Hansen, an economics professor, notes that allegations of police misconduct are more common around pretextual stops than core safety-related violations. Biases and fairness have always been a challenge in law enforcement, and removing enforcement can lead to faster driving and a loss for society.
Automated Enforcement: A Limited Solution
Local governments in Suffolk and Nassau have automated enforcement programs, such as red light cameras and school bus-arm cameras, which issue hundreds of thousands of notices of liability each year. While these programs are not included in Newsday's analysis, they are limited to specific violations and do not establish who was driving.
"Red light cameras are useful, but they're no substitute for in-person tickets," says Stuart Cameron, a former Suffolk County police chief.
Expanding Enforcement: A Costly Endeavor
Police departments on Long Island are among the highest-paid in the state, and Suffolk County's budget has expanded the department. Commissioner Catalina has added officers to the highway patrol, but he acknowledges the limitations. "We'd need 20,000 officers if we could, but we're doing our best with what we have," he says.
The Community's Voice: A Call for Action
April Acquila, a Mount Sinai resident, echoes the need for more police presence and ticketing in her area. "Speeding drivers are a menace," she says, "and more enforcement would help."
Conclusion: A Complex Balance
The debate over ticketing and traffic enforcement on Long Island highlights the complex balance between public safety, resources, and community needs. While ticketing is a crucial tool, it's just one piece of the puzzle in ensuring our roads are safe. As the debate continues, one thing is clear: We all have a role to play in keeping our streets secure.
What's your take on this issue? Share your thoughts in the comments below!
